Hello Gary, you have written acclaimed novels and award-winning plays. How does your approach to storytelling change when you’re writing for the stage versus writing a novel?
When you write a play, it’s collaborative. You give it to the actors, director. They’ll interpret your work even when they don’t change a word because they embody the vision and the characters. You also must tailor the story to a live audience, seeking the immediacy of the moment. With a novel, it’s all yours, good or bad. But unlike a play where the audience sees your world, a novel is left in the hands of the reader to use their imagination. Yes you describe things, but my blue isn’t your blue. In both instances, once the story leaves your hands, it belongs to someone else.
Your work often explores family, identity, and moral choices. What draws you to these deeply human themes, and why do you think they continue to resonate with readers and audiences?
To me, they’re the essence of society, the very core of our relationships, the bonds, failed, successful, the longing and searching for love, for connections. Everyone can identify with family, with struggling to do the right thing, finding your soulmate, loving your child and hoping they’ll love you back.
In Jesse’s Girl, Teddy Mentor risks everything to find his adopted son. What inspired you to tell a story about the extraordinary lengths a parent will go to for their child?
I published Jesse’s Girl on Amazon in 2009. My son, my only child, was in the throes of addiction. His mother and I went all over the country placing him in substance abuse programs. I hoped that Jesse’s Girl would shake him awake to what he was doing to himself. It didn’t work. After he passed, I put the novel into an emotional vault. Then a friend read the original and strongly urged me to revisit it. I wrote new drafts, editing, updating. Ultimately the novel asks how much should a parent sacrifice for their child. In Jesse’s Girl, the answer is everything.
The novel combines emotional family drama with a fast-paced thriller. How did you balance the emotional journey of the characters with the suspense of the story?
At the end, it’s always about the characters. What they do determines the plot. It must be organic. The relationships, the heart, the soul, the search makes the story. And there’s a lot of twists and turns in Jesse’s Girl.

As a playwright, dialogue is one of your greatest strengths. Did your experience writing for the stage influence the conversations and pacing in Jesse’s Girl?
There is a fluidity between the genres as long as you remember the differences. With a novel you have the ability to invite the readers into the characters’ thoughts: rambling, neurotic, uncertain, brave. With a play you have a time element – you don’t see any three act plays anymore – where with a novel you can go on for as long as you need. Ultimately a story has the same elements and the same foundations. It must engage and entertain.
Many of your stories feature flawed but deeply relatable characters. What is your process for creating characters that readers can empathize with, even when they make difficult or imperfect choices? Readers want to see people they understand and know, who are like them so they can put themselves into the character’s shoes. Flawed and broken people interest me because that was my family. When you’re writing, the trick is getting out of the way. Once the characters have come through the door from the other side, whatever you want to call it, I let them develop. I don’t always agree with my characters; sometimes I’m appalled by their behavior. I never stop a character from doing something wrong because that’s what we all do, how we learn. We get the thrill when we see the character go to their knees, where we’ve all been at some point, and get up. That’s not heroic. That’s human.
The wilderness program at the beginning of Jesse’s Girl immediately raises questions about trust, parenting, and redemption. What kind of conversations were you hoping the novel would spark among readers?
I want the parents in the room to identify with the difficulty of having a difficult child, whether the issue is rooted in substance abuse or not. Since there are so many conflicting emotions and challenges involved in being a parent, I want to show how hard it is. And sometimes, like me, you lose.
Your career spans theater, fiction, and political and social commentary. How has your voice as a writer evolved over the years, and what has remained constant throughout your creative journey?
The joy of creating. Yeah, the blank page is terrifying. But once the magic begins there is nothing quite like touching another person with your words. Evoking emotions, laughter. In our crazy world we need more of that because the theme that runs through my work is that there’s more that unites us than divides us.
You’ve received recognition for both your plays and novels. Is there a particular project that challenged you the most or changed you as a writer? Why?
Jesse’s Girl, because I was swimming, hey, treading water in a sea of pain and emotion. I didn’t know quite how to handle everything to make it a coherent novel until I realized I wasn’t going to write about what really happened. There are only two actual incidents in the novel. I figured out that I should just pour the feelings into a creative food processor so the story and the characters are all fictionalized.
For aspiring writers who dream of succeeding in multiple genres, what advice would you give about developing a unique voice while remaining open to different forms of storytelling?
Don’t be afraid to be honest. Don’t pull punches or restrain your characters because you’re afraid someone will get upset. I’m not talking about gratuitous tricks like language or sex or violence. That’s okay if it’s organic to the story, but not if it’s used to shock. Write what you know and what you feel, accepting that there’ll be folks who won’t like it. To me, writing is like inviting the reader or audience to eavesdrop on the characters in their most unguarded moments. Imagine someone watching you 24/7. That wouldn’t be too embarrassing, right? But it would be real and someone who has spent money and time with your story deserves the truth. Not necessarily a universal truth, but your truth.
Find out more about Gary at: https://www.instagram.com/garymorgenstein/
